[dini-ag-kim-identifier] Http-URIs for items

[Kai Eckert]

Hi list,

provided that you mean the manifestation with $resourceID, this would 
not help in our case, as we have several identical items under the same 
signature under the same bibliographic record, i.e., manifestation.

Example:

http://vs30.kobv.de/primo_library/libweb/action/display.do?doc=MAN_ALEPH001101864&scp.scps=&vid=MAN_UB

Click on "Standorte"/"Locations" and then "Lehrbuchsammlung".

Of course all these items are identical, but maybe you still would like 
to distinguish them, if you want to identify and handle the real, 
physical books.

Cheers,

Kai

Am 19.04.2012 16:42, schrieb Pascal Christoph:
> Hello list,
>
> at KIM Workshop 12. April it was mentioned to maybe close
> dini-ag-kim-identifier because of too low traffic. It was also discussed to
> begin a discussion at dini-ag-kim-lld at maybe move a thread if its worth to
> the more specialised list.
>
> (In my opinion this discussion list _may_ help us, so I give it a try )
>
> However...
> At lobid.org we were wondering how to mint http-URIs for library items
> (exemplars)[1] and come to the conclusion that "the following form would be the
> best:
>
> http://lobid.org/item/$resourceID:$signature
>
> i.e.
>
> http://lobid.org/item/HT000494055:3E+6294
>
> because we discovered (example missing) that it may occur that one signature
> denotes in fact multiple, different items , even if it is in one and the same
> organisation. With the conjunction of resource ID and signature we avoid any
> possible ambiguities."[2]
>
> This is really a minor thing because at least there will be only some 0.0..1%
> of URIs affected, but then:
>
> 1. URIs should always identify one thing and
> 2. they are arbitrary
>
> So why not use my suggested shape to be at the save side?
>
> Another thing:
> I know that b3kat and Jakob Voss actually use URIs like this:
> http://lod.b3kat.de/bib/<ISIL>/item/<Katalognummer>   [3]
>
> but then these are not URIs for an item but rather a URI for a whole lot of
> items. How will you be able to i.e. say anything like "item A is lend, but item
> B is available"? Or "item A is in a good condition, item B is in bad condition" ?
>
> Any comments?
>
> -o
>
> [1]https://wiki1.hbz-nrw.de/display/SEM/2012/02/10/lobid.org+news#lobid.orgnews-ItemURIschanged
> [2]https://wiki1.hbz-nrw.de/display/SEM/2012/04/19https://wiki1.hbz-nrw.de/display/SEM/2012/04/19
> [3]http://lod.b3kat.de/doc/update_2012-01-04.html
> _______________________________________________
> dini-ag-kim-identifier mailing list
> dini-ag-kim-identifier at lists.d-nb.de
> http://lists.d-nb.de/mailman/listinfo/dini-ag-kim-identifier
>

-- 
Kai Eckert
Universitätsbibliothek Mannheim
Stellv. Leiter Abteilung Digitale Bibliotheksdienste
Schloss Schneckenhof West / 68131 Mannheim
Tel. 0621/181-2946 Fax 0621/181-2918